Best B&Bs on Block Island | Top Stays at Avonlea & Blue Dory Inn

Looking for the best B&Bs on Block Island?

There’s a reason visitors fall in love with Block Island—and it’s not just the beaches and bluff views. The Island has a special way of making you slow down, breathe deeper, and truly settle into vacation mode. One of the best ways to experience that magic is by staying in a bed and breakfast, where the hospitality feels personal, the atmosphere feels cozy, and the details make all the difference.

If you’re searching for the best B&Bs on Block Island, you’ll find a range of charming options, from historic inns to oceanfront hideaways. But two properties consistently rise to the top for their locations, guest experience, and unforgettable island charm: Avonlea and The Blue Dory Inn.

1. Avonlea: A True Jewel of the Sea

If your ideal getaway includes ocean views, peaceful mornings, and a true sense of retreat, Avonlea is hard to beat. This adults-only bed and breakfast sits directly on the beach, offering what many guests describe as some of the most breathtaking views on the island. It’s the kind of place where you wake up to the sound of waves, step onto the porch with coffee in hand, and feel like the rest of the world has gone wonderfully quiet.

Avonlea is known for its elevated, romantic atmosphere—perfect for honeymoons, anniversaries, or couples who simply want time away together. Rooms are thoughtfully designed, with coastal touches that feel refined rather than themed. All feature en suite, private bathrooms (some with Jacuzzi tubs), cozy seating areas, and windows that make the Atlantic feel like part of your room.

The experience is also beautifully curated: mornings begin with a complimentary New England breakfast, and afternoons invite you to unwind with wine, light bites, and the inn’s famous Block Island Barnacle Cookies. When people talk about the best B&Bs on Block Island, Avonlea often tops the list because it feels like a true escape—quiet, luxurious, and effortlessly coastal.

2. The Blue Dory Inn: A Beloved Island Classic

For a warm, welcoming stay that blends classic charm with one of the best locations on the island, The Blue Dory Inn is a must. This beautifully updated Victorian-style inn sits right at the head of Crescent Beach and is just a short walk from the ferry, shops, and many of the island’s best restaurants—meaning you can arrive, drop your bags, and start vacation immediately.

What makes The Blue Dory Inn so special is how easy it feels. It’s relaxed, friendly, and filled with character. Guests love the homey touches, the beach access just steps away, and the sense of tradition—this is the kind of place people return to year after year.

The Blue Dory also offers a major bonus for many travelers: pet-friendly accommodations in select rooms, so you don’t have to leave your furry family member behind. Like Avonlea, it also offers complimentary breakfast and afternoon treats, giving your stay that classic B&B feeling of being genuinely cared for.

If you want a stay that’s charming, convenient, and quintessentially Block Island, this is one of the best B&Bs on Block Island to book.

What to Look for When Choosing the Best B&B

The “best” bed and breakfast depends on the kind of trip you’re planning. Here are a few quick ways to decide:

For romance and quiet: Avonlea’s adults-only, oceanfront setting is ideal.
For convenience and classic charm: The Blue Dory Inn puts you close to town and right on the beach.
For longer stays or extra space: Consider one of our cottages if you want a more spacious and private experience.

Book Your Block Island B&B Experience

A bed and breakfast stay is more than a place to sleep—it’s part of the vacation. The right B&B sets the tone for the entire trip, from the first morning coffee to the last sunset stroll.

If you’re searching for the best B&Bs on Block Island, start with Avonlea and The Blue Dory Inn—two unforgettable stays that offer the island’s most loved combination: ocean views, thoughtful hospitality, and the kind of comfort that keeps guests coming back.

See all availability and get the best rates when you book directly on BlockIslandInns.com or call us at 401-466-5891.

[mhr_line_break]

FAQ: Best B&Bs on Block Island

What are the best B&Bs on Block Island?

Many travelers consider Avonlea and The Blue Dory Inn among the best B&Bs on Block Island thanks to their oceanfront locations, welcoming hospitality, and memorable guest experiences.

Which Block Island B&B is best for couples?

For couples looking for a romantic getaway, Avonlea is a top choice. Its adults-only setting, peaceful atmosphere, and breathtaking ocean views make it ideal for anniversaries, honeymoons, and weekend escapes.

Which Block Island B&B is closest to the ferry?

The Blue Dory Inn is just a short walk from the ferry and Old Harbor. It’s a great option if you want an easy arrival, quick access to town, and the beach right outside your door.

Are there pet-friendly B&Bs on Block Island?

Yes! The Blue Dory Inn offers pet-friendly accommodations in select rooms, making it a popular pick for travelers who want to bring their dog to Block Island.

Do Block Island B&Bs include breakfast?

Many do, and both Avonlea and The Blue Dory Inn offer complimentary breakfast, a classic B&B perk that helps you start the day off right before exploring the island.

Is it worth staying at a B&B instead of a hotel on Block Island?

If you want a more personal and relaxing experience, a B&B is a great choice. Guests often love the cozy atmosphere, thoughtful extras, and local hospitality that make B&B stays feel more special and memorable than standard hotels.